In 4th grade, I had to do my math homework on graph paper, with precise numbers of squares between my answers. I could never get it right... Lots of late nights crying, feeling stupid. Now I appreciate that having the answers in a grid is much easier to grade. As a student it was torture. I loved the problem solving aspect, but the way it was graded destroyed my confidence.
I had an art teacher who was also a family friend, who gave me a book of Origami. Tomoko Fuse's classic, 'Multidimensional Transformations.' I've spent thousands of hours in a flow state executing her designs and exploring different types of symmetry. I will forever be in her debt.
Your story about Minute Math and the graph paper homework captures how mechanical constraints can crush a student's love for actual problem solving. When you are in the classroom, how do you plan to design math assessments that evaluate true understanding without creating that kind of processing torture for your students?
ReplyDelete