In math 11, before I fell in love with the subject, I had intense frustration with 2*2 matrix multiplication. I struggled to remember which index was which, and the long formulas for each element were not intuitive. The 3*3 case was even worse. No amount of practice made it click. Then it all changed when the TA, a grad student, told me the secret... Just dot the row with the column! Why had no one ever said that? All of a sudden, any matrix size had a simple procedure for determining its products. The formulas which had vexed me so needed not even to be written. My love affair with matrix algebra began on that day.
What elements led to my breakthrough? The eureka moment was perhaps an example of what Skemp calls relational understanding. In a flash, I got a glimpse of what matrix multiplication really was. But in another sense, it was clearly instrumental understanding. Indeed, it was a process I could use to get the correct answer to a given problem. It relied upon another instrumental understanding, the fact that I knew what the dot product was. My thesis is that these two ways of understanding are not mutually exclusive. A successful math teacher must be mindful of both and how they support eachother.
The example of the error made when computing an area with incorrect units highlights a new goal in relational understanding. Let us treat each mathematical instrument, such as a procedure of multiplying length and width, as a heuristic. Then once a heuristic is learned, then the next important task that we must take on is to map the limits of validity of that heuristic. So many mistakes in reasoning come down to inappropriate applications of heuristics.
As with many aspects of education, there is a practical aspect, that Skemp notes that relational understanding is more difficult to quantify than instrumental. Perhaps this is itself a misapplication of the heuristic that all understanding must be quantified and used to sort and rank students. Another way of describing this mistake is 'putting the cart before the horse.'
What an interesting post that made me stop and think several times! I completely agree with your thoughts of what a successful math teach must do and I am curious how you will go about this? Your own experience demonstrates that your success was as a result of the TA, not the teacher. What is your take away from that?
ReplyDeleteFascinating contemplation on the ways that relational and instrumental understanding inevitably entwine, and can't truly be separated! Thanks Adam.
ReplyDelete